Skip to Main Content

Under a Hot Bench: The Joy of Wabash Moot Court

After the fact, the moot court finalists all talked about wanting a hot bench. Well, they got their wish.

In moot court parlance, a “hot bench” is one where the judges’ questions come in rapid-fire succession. It can feel unrelenting.

Four words. That’s how far finalist Elijah Wetzel ’27 got before the first question came.

Elijah Wetzel '27 (left) and Owen Smith '27 enjoy a light moment during the Moot Court final.“There’s always going to be some nerves just because this environment creates that,” Wetzel said. “The questions are kind of reassuring. They let you know what the judges are thinking about, what they care about in the case, and what they’re curious about. When you get a question, you have to have the mindset, ‘This is an opportunity, not some sort of attack from the outside.’”

Fellow finalist John Jarosz ’28 also welcomed the relentless questioning and revealed an underlying truth.

“We don't have enough material written down and I don’t think anyone would want to hear us just read off what we have for 12 minutes,” he explained. “Getting to answer those kinds of questions and piggyback off what the judges say allows us to maneuver and make our own points. That is where the magic happens.”

The featured case had issues that dealt with both the Second and Fifth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. ItFinalist John Jarosz ’28 delivers his argument. examined whether states have the authority to ban AR-15-style rifles and large capacity magazines to prevent mass shootings. Arising from a law enacted by the fictional State of Blue following a mass shooting at an elementary school and in response to growing concerns about gun violence, the state legislature adopted the Act Addressing Gun Violence (Act A123), which prohibits the sale and possession of AR-15-style rifles and magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition.

Judge James R. Sweeney, Chief Justice, United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, praised the authors of the case in crafting a balanced case for both sides. Then he praised the participants for handling the case well under stressful conditions.

“What a great job the writers of this problem did to try to make it even on both sides,” Sweeney said. “That’s a tough thing to do, and invariably, it’s not enough. What we look at is how you did in playing the hand you were dealt. Overall, the competition was strong, especially when you are on the clock, which adds additional pressure.”

Owen Smith ’27 was named top advocate by the judges. Participants often have to argue both sides of the case as they advance through the competition. The mathematics and computer science major appreciated the challenge of studying this case from all angles.

“It's a lot of work in the beginning, especially the prelims, being able to differentiate what side you like more, or how best to attack both problems,” he said. “I had to switch my argument when I got to the finals, so I’m going back and forth, deciding which hill I’ll die on. The ability to spend so much time on a problem, to dissect both sides, and think on your feet is not only a great skill for classes or the law, but it’s also a great life skill.”

Wade Wisler ’27 prepares to face the judges.Justice James Joven ’89, a Marion Superior Court judge, cited the opportunity for growth in what many involved in moot court call the quintessential liberal arts experience.

“This is a growth opportunity that I hope many more of your classmates and those to come will partake in,” said Joven. “I am constantly amazed with the quality of the arguments that students put forth during these moot court competitions. You never let me down.”

The rewards of this experience extend beyond the judging. Smith appreciated the competition and being tested on the skill that Wabash prides itself most.

”If you look at the four pillars of Wabash, the first one is to think critically,” he said. “Nothing tests you on that aspect any better than moot court does. I’m an analytical thinker put in an environment where I can apply it to a real-world problem in the eyes of the law and work through it. You take all these skills you have for this one big moment, and you put it together and do the best you can.”

Finalist Wade Wisler ’27 pointed to something different.

“I’ll remember the camaraderie the most,” said the PPE and art double major. “I always enjoy conversations with fellow competitors about how they’ve approached their arguments, the hours they’ve spent preparing, and the tough questions they got from the bench. Moot court is always rewarding as an individual, but most enjoyable when shared with colleagues.”

Back to Top