The Art of the Question

 
  
 
 
  
   "The art of Samuel Bak entrances. It also disquiets."
  
  
   So write Wabash College Dean of the College Gary Phillips and Drew 
   University Theological School Professor Danna Fewell in their 
   introduction to the catalog for "The Art of the Question: The Paintings 
   of Samuel Bak," which opens Monday, March 2 in the Eric Dean Gallery at 
   the College's Fine Arts Center.
  
  
   In this album you'll find a sampling from the many works in the 
   exhibition, along with some of the teaching material Professors Phillips 
   and Fewell, have prepared for the show.
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Creation of Wartime III"
  
  
   The various figures of Adam in soiled uniform, prison coveralls, or 
   refugee garb are contemporary representatives of the one who was 
   banished from Paradise. Like him they must feel that they were dumped 
   into this world, unasked. How can they rise from the rubble where they 
   have landed? Perhaps this explains why they are all in search of God. 
   The most they come up with in my paintings is some mysterious shape, 
   perhaps a hand that signals meaning they must discover themselves.
  
  
    My imagery derives, of course, from Michelangelo’s Creation of Man, at 
   whose center Gods and Adam’s pointing fingers almost touch. What do 
   these fingers mean to me? The hands seem to be of similar size. Is God 
   creating man in his image, or is this man’s creation of God? Could their 
   gestures express any disappointment or accusation?
  
  
   —Samuel Bak
  
  
   
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Figure with Flight Assistant"
  
  
   The angel takes a different form in "Figure with Flight Assistant," 
   being simultaneously angel, airplane, and Icarus, whose inventor father 
   Daedalus may or may not be the character with the breathing apparatus 
   whose hose is in Icarus’s hand. Whatever their identity beneath their 
   respective half-masks (between one’s goggles and the other’s mask they 
   expose a single complete face) their destinies are intertwined: they 
   have begun together to seek the means of human flight and eventual 
   freedom.
  
  
   —Paul T. Nagano, Samuel Bak: The Past Continues
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "The Nature of Roots"
  
  
   The spiritually complex and perilous journey from ruin to restoration is 
   embodied in the difficulty of the transit, a process vividly dramatized 
   by a painting like "The Nature of Roots," where Bak’s fondness for 
   fusing disparate materials results in a ladder with tree roots for a 
   base.
  
  
   Here many roles have been transformed. Once it was the nature of roots 
   to plunge deeper into the earth in quest of life-giving moisture. The 
   Jewish equivalent of that pursuit has been brutally severed by Nazi 
   expulsions – a favorite German euphemism for extermination was 
   ausrotten, to uproot.
  
  
   But since the putting down of physical roots in a Jewish homeland always 
   implied a spiritual yearning for a heavenly connection, Bak’s torn up 
   roots become a ladder raised toward the sky.
  
  
   The damage done below, however, has its parallel in the rent above, a 
   far more portentous injury, since roots are portable, if salvaged in 
   time, in a way that spirit is not.
  
  
   An anonymous angel gestures with the ever-present hand, but who can read 
   accurately its enigmatic signal – if signal it is, and not a hopeless 
   wave of frustration?
  
  
   —Lawrence Langer, In a Different Light: The Book of Genesis in 
   the Art of Samuel Bak
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "For the Many Davids"
  
  
   The young biblical David takes up unconventional arms to defend the name 
   of God. Indeed he claims his victory will be proof “that there is a God 
   in Israel.” 
  
  
   But while the David of biblical tradition triumphs, other Davids do not. 
   And we are led to wonder, yet again, how the survival or demise of 
   children and the presence of God are possibly related, and why we tell 
   stories in which children must defend God rather than the other way 
   around.
  
  
   —Danna Nolan Fewell and Gary A Phillips, Icon of Loss: The 
   Haunting Child of Samuel Bak
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Holding a Promise"
  
  
   A downcast young Noah stands ready to launch a tiny skiff. A tattered 
   rainbow provides its rigging.
  
  
   Has the promise of heavenly protection been restored? Or has the boy 
   cobbled together his own means of escape, crafting a refugee boat that 
   will set sail under his direction and power? He carries no cargo besides 
   himself and a bundle of sticks. Is this kindling intended for a 
   thanksgiving sacrifice to God once the flood has been safely navigated? 
   Or has this little Noah become Isaac, carrying wood for another burnt 
   offering orchestrated under false pretenses? Exactly what promise does 
   he portend? And what is its price?
  
  
   —Danna Nolan Fewell and Gary A Phillips, Icon of Loss: The 
   Haunting Child of Samuel Bak
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Solo"
  
  
   Do Bak’s musicians frozen in a world of disrepair—suggesting a 
   performance but not actually playing—raise the question of whether or 
   not art has been trumped by the atrocities of the Shoah, or whether 
   hearing the music we once knew, or any music at all, is simply too much 
   of an indulgence given what we have we have seen? 
  
  
   Has the time for music-making ended?
  
  
    —Charles Rix, “The End of Time: Bak’s Art, Messiaen’s Music, and 
   Levinas’s Ethics”
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Walled In", 2008
  
  
   Here we see shades of the film Hitler loved so well: Fritz Lang’s 
   futuristic silent film Metropolis where workers’ bodies are ground into 
   dust and made into cement to build and operate the city that enslaves 
   them. Future fantasy becomes past fact as we witness children becoming 
   the fungible raw materials needed for fuel and defense in the Nazi 
   extermination campaign. 
  
  
   —Danna Nolan Fewell and Gary A Phillips, Icon of Loss: The 
   Haunting Child of Samuel Bak
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Persistence"
  
  
   Old, blue pages,
Purple traces on silver hair,
Words on parchment, created
Through thousands of years in despair.
As if protecting a baby
I run, bearing Jewish words,
I grope in every courtyard:
The spirit won’t be murdered by the hordes.
I reach my arm into the bonfire and am happy:
I got it, bravo! Mine are Amsterdam,
Worms, Livorno, Madrid, and YIVO.
How tormented am I by a page
Carried off by the smoke and winds!
Hidden poems come and choke me:
– Hide us in your labyrinth! —from Abraham Sutzkever, “Grains of Wheat”
						
					Purple traces on silver hair,
Words on parchment, created
Through thousands of years in despair.
As if protecting a baby
I run, bearing Jewish words,
I grope in every courtyard:
The spirit won’t be murdered by the hordes.
I reach my arm into the bonfire and am happy:
I got it, bravo! Mine are Amsterdam,
Worms, Livorno, Madrid, and YIVO.
How tormented am I by a page
Carried off by the smoke and winds!
Hidden poems come and choke me:
– Hide us in your labyrinth! —from Abraham Sutzkever, “Grains of Wheat”

 
  
 
 
  
   "Memorial"
  
  
   The fractured, pieced together tablets of the Ten Commandments stand 
   simultaneously as a metaphor of the Sinai covenant that has been broken 
   by both humanity and God and as a headstone memorializing the six 
   million Jewish martyrs of the Shoah. The monument stands as though to 
   mark “Here lie the dead.” 
  
  
   But the bodies are not to be found nor is the god who once brought the 
   people out of the land of Egypt. The tablets stand in, mark a place, for 
   an absent deity and a missing people. Rusting double yods, letters 
   signifying the divine name, have been manually riveted to the top of one 
   of the tablets, a seemingly desperate and wishful imposition of divine 
   presence. 
  
  
   The people themselves are present only in traces: A dismembered and 
   roughly re-membered Star of David becomes the central picture of the 
   tablets’ puzzle, its form a sad example of the stone cutter’s and iron 
   worker’s arts. Here the identity of a people is pieced back together 
   after historical rupture, the rupture now integral to the identity of 
   those who are lost and those who remain, an insistent but uneasy 
   cohesion in an unstable and damaged structure. 
  
  
   The people are also engraved in the number 6, which alludes doubly to 
   the six million who perished in the Shoah and to the sixth commandment 
   “Thou shall not kill.” The number 6 both grieves and accuses. Implicated 
   in this cipher, as well as in the barbed wire, the prison-striped 
   salvage, the metal stays, and the bullet holes, are both the victims and 
   the perpetrators. Unspeakable suffering and the violence that has caused 
   it are inextricably bound together.
  
  
   —Danna Nolan Fewell and Gary A. Phillips, “From Bak to the Bible: 
   Imagination, Interpretation, and Tikkun Olam”
  
 
						
					
 
  
 
 
  
   "Under a Blue Sky"
  
  
   High in the wind and sun was my dwelling-place,
motherland, now you chain in the valley of
shadow your broken son; no comfort
now are the heavenly games of evening. Over the cliffs the skyscape is shining; I
dwelling in the depths, and stones are my company,
speechless; should I then be as they are?
Why do you write? Is it death? Who asks you?— Asks of your life a reckoning, asks of this
fragment of poem how it remains but a
fragment? Know this: unmourned, unburied,
I shall lie graveless, no vale shall rock me. Winds shall disperse my leavings; but listen, the
cliff shall re-echo – today, or tomorrow – the
song I am singing; boys and girls are
growing up now who will hear its meaning.
—Miklós Radnóti, “In a Troubled Hour”
January 10, 1939
						
					motherland, now you chain in the valley of
shadow your broken son; no comfort
now are the heavenly games of evening. Over the cliffs the skyscape is shining; I
dwelling in the depths, and stones are my company,
speechless; should I then be as they are?
Why do you write? Is it death? Who asks you?— Asks of your life a reckoning, asks of this
fragment of poem how it remains but a
fragment? Know this: unmourned, unburied,
I shall lie graveless, no vale shall rock me. Winds shall disperse my leavings; but listen, the
cliff shall re-echo – today, or tomorrow – the
song I am singing; boys and girls are
growing up now who will hear its meaning.
—Miklós Radnóti, “In a Troubled Hour”
January 10, 1939

